Tips Today Losing Fatty Alongside Uncomplicated Food-- 2 Reader Anecdotes

Each week, I'm receiving to a greater extent than e-mails together with comments from people who are successfully losing fatty yesteryear eating unproblematic (low reward) food, similar to what I described here.  In some cases, people are breaking through fatty loss plateaus that they had reached on conventional low-carbohydrate, low-fat or paleo diets.  This concept tin go applied to whatsoever type of diet, together with I believe it is an of import feature of ancestral nutrient patterns.

At the Ancestral Health Symposium, I met 2 readers, Aravind Balasubramanian together with Kamal Patel, who were interested inwards trying a unproblematic diet to lose fatty together with improve their health.  In addition, they wanted to intermission complimentary of for certain other high-reward activities inwards their lives that they felt were non constructive.  They lately embarked on an 8-week low-reward diet together with lifestyle to exam the effectiveness of the concepts.  Both of them had previously achieved a stable (in Aravind's case, reduced) weight on a paleo-ish diet prior to this experiment, but they silent carried to a greater extent than fatty than they wanted to.  They offered to write close their experience for WHS, together with I thought other readers mightiness observe it informative.  Their story is below, followed yesteryear a few of my comments.

Introduction

In the summertime of 2011, Aravind together with Kamal were intrigued yesteryear the possibility of achieving a healthier mental together with physical solid seat down based on ideas presented yesteryear physician Guyenet inwards his Food Reward series. Both wanted to lose weight together with disconnect from the Internet. Additionally, Aravind wanted to address long-standing slumber issues together with a severe diet soda addiction, spell Kamal wanted to explore the potential benefits inwards dealing amongst chronic articulation hurting issues (Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome). After care AHS11, nosotros embarked upon a Low Reward Lifestyle experiment on August 15, 2011 to unscientifically exam the ideas discussed amongst honor to Food together with Technology Reward.

Kamal Patel

●     Age – 31

●     Target weight              – 150 lbs

●     August 15, 2011          – 169 lbs

●     September 12, 2011   – 159 lbs (Week 4)

●     October 10, 2011        – 157 lbs (Week 8)

Aravind Balasubramanian

●     Age - 42

●     Target weight              – 160 lbs

●     August 15, 2011          – 180 lbs

●     September 12, 2011   – 172 lbs (Week 4)

●     October 10, 2011        – 168 lbs (Week 8)

Food Reward

Prior to the experiment, both of us were eating a “Paleo” diet amongst occasional cheats. Aravind started 2011 at 195 lbs together with lost xv lbs inside half dozen weeks, transitioning from a SAD vegetarian diet to an Archevore vegetarian diet. For the side yesteryear side half dozen months, he remained weight stable at 180 lbs. Kamal started Paleo inwards 2009 at 170 lbs, together with was fairly weight-stable during the yesteryear 2 years.

Using the concepts outlined, nosotros essentially implemented Levels 1-4. Elements of Level 5 were implemented to the extent at that topographic point was monotony twenty-four hours over day. Within whatsoever given day, however, at that topographic point was variety. We kept a nutrient diary of everything eaten, though did non count or deliberately confine calories. You volition depository fiscal establishment annotation that nosotros followed radically dissimilar protocols inwards damage of diet composition together with macronutrients. Metrics receive got been calculated ex post.

Representative Daily Diets

- Kamal

●     Breakfast - Berries, Milk poly peptide isolate (unflavored)

●     Lunch - Beef stew (beef, carrot, celery, salt, pepper), Banana

●     Dinner - Steamed fish (fish, salt, pepper, lemon juice), manifestly spinach, manifestly squash, Tiny chip of walnuts

●     Snacks - None. Started eating sushi during re-feeds after on. Ate to a greater extent than seasoned Paleo foods amongst added fatty on rare occasions (e.g. BBQ, travelling, hot date)

●     Calories 1100-1200 per day, 3000-4000 on 1x/week re-feed days amongst added rice

●     Macronutrients 50% protein, 30% carbohydrates, 20% fatty (high % poly peptide was to minimize musculus loss due to extremely depression calorie consumption)

- Aravind

●     Breakfast – boiled eggs, sweetness potatoes (or whole milk amongst whey poly peptide if rushed)

●     Lunch – White rice amongst ghee, greenish vegetables (okra, spinach, broccoli) cooked inwards piffling ghee without spices, total fatty (homemade) yogurt

●     Dinner – White rice amongst traditionally prepared lentils, white potatoes, greenish vegetables, together with yogurt; Or spinach salad amongst mixed veggies, boiled eggs, together with “ghee vinaigrette”

●     Snacks – 85-90% black chocolate, macadamia nuts, bananas (eliminated in 1 lawsuit diet soda addiction overcome)

●     Calories 1700-1800 per day

●     Macronutrients 55% carbohydrates, 25% fat, 20% poly peptide (pre-experiment 45% carbs, albeit higher overall calorie consumption)

●     Dietary staples remained unchanged, withal seasonings, salt, spices, added fats significantly reduced. Diet soda eliminated. Very express alcohol consumption

Adaptation together with Satiety

After adapting to a lower vantage diet, satiety was non at all a problem. However the fourth dimension to arrange was radically dissimilar for the 2 of us.

Kamal was able to transition almost immediately, together with inwards spite of running a pregnant caloric deficit, was non hungry at all. Kamal ate essentially the same matter every unmarried twenty-four hours (except for a twenty-four hours of re-feed every calendar week or 2 that consisted of 3000-4000 kcals for leptin resetting, amongst extra carbs inwards the shape of rice). Prior to the experiment, he did non receive got whatsoever liquid addictions-- alone consuming 1 loving cup of java inwards his whole life, together with drinking alcohol in 1 lawsuit every dyad of months. Perhaps most of import was the utilisation of a irksome cooker. Every 3 days, he would brand a unproblematic beef stew, which anchored the next days meals without exerting whatsoever essay at all. Occasionally, a turnip or taro would go thrown inwards to add together some “excitement” but would essay to go besides disgusting or irritating to the gut.

Aravind, however, had a real serious addiction to diet soda (3 liters per day) prior to the experiment. The calendar week earlier starting, he titrated downward to address caffeine withdrawal symptoms. The start 10-14 days of the experiment, Aravind was RAVENOUS, much to his surprise. Compliance was maintained strictly though willpower. Perhaps the extreme hunger was similar to chain smokers that halt smoking. However, after the psychological withdrawal subsided at the destination of calendar week 2, hunger levels returned to normal inwards calendar week 3 together with satiety was no longer an issue. Snacking was eventually eliminated equally good given reduced hunger. Aravind has non consumed whatsoever diet soda since August 15th after a decade+ addiction.

Adherence

After physically together with psychologically adapting, adherence has been tardily equally long equally the surroundings is controlled. In our typical daily lives (home/work), the powerfulness to create simply-prepared nutrient made it tardily to comply. However social settings are peculiarly challenging since rewarding foods together with drinks are EVERYWHERE, along amongst overcoming the many years of conditioning where emotionally challenging situations final result inwards stress relief via comfort foods, fifty-fifty if high character “Paleo approved”. It should go noted that for all intents together with purposes, nosotros did non cheat over the course of education of the 8 weeks.

Notwithstanding social together with emotional pressures, our experience is that it is real hard to overeat on a really depression vantage diet. Paleo diets irrespective of their macronutrient composition tin silent go real rewarding together with spell nosotros create non wishing to engage inwards a fence close the tautology of calories inwards / calories out, the bottom business is that the First Law of Thermodynamics silent applies. Physics is non exactly a practiced idea, it’s the law!

The other fundamental element to adherence was the back upwardly organisation nosotros had inwards place. We spoke to each other daily together with kept a shared Google Doc diet log. Co-sponsoring 1 some other was the start of Rewardaholics Anonymous. The bulk of the back upwardly was to address Tech Reward (see below), but inwards the early on, this was beneficial all around. We realize that having a back upwardly organisation has aught specifically to create amongst Low Reward, but wanted to betoken out that both of us receive got derived a lot of forcefulness from “RA” together with hence equally to non cheat.

Additionally, during the course of education of the experiment, at that topographic point was a notable shift amongst honor to the role of food. Food has transitioned from a origin of amusement to fuel. Some people receive got commented that they observe this highly objectionable. Being “epicurious” or a foodie seems inherently incongruent amongst an ancestral dietary approach. This is non a re-enactment declaration existence made. Perhaps those that receive got plateaued after a substantial weight loss (but inwards a higher identify a salubrious laid point) consider this if additional weight loss is desired. It has worked for us. YMMV.

Sustainability

Aravind’s electrical flow diet is expected to the heart of his long term diet. The alone expected alter is occasional cheats (mostly alcohol) but has no intention to go dorsum to a substantially higher vantage diet equally he feels it is completely sustainable. He structured his experiment diet equally such to avoid a hard transition after together with mayhap regain the weight. Kamal’s time to come diet is unknown. He embarked on this experiment to both lose weight together with arrange to a simpler lifestyle. Kamal is non a natural at Paleo though - he is non a big meat or vegetable fan. This diet has notably improved on the vegetable role though. Kamal is at nowadays satisfied eating manifestly spinach, broccoli, together with squash. His time to come diet volition probable go similar to the electrical flow diet but amongst added fatty together with starches together with much less protein. The amount of seasoning together with cheats is silent upwardly for pondering.

Reward is non synonymous amongst palatability, though correlated. Aravind finds his diet rather palatable or it would non go his long term diet. Related to this, previously unsatisfying depression vantage foods receive got go satisfying after the adaption occurred. This is non to say that hyper-rewarding foods receive got go unsatisfying or undesirable – it would go disingenuous to advise otherwise. Therefore, at that topographic point volition go ever go an chemical element of willpower to pace away from the cake, cookies, pizza, etc. However, this is no dissimilar than whatsoever other diet where previously desirable foods demand to go avoided.  Like an alcoholic, the rewardaholic needs to consider his/her trigger foods together with abstain, or go willing to receive got the consequences. 

Technology Reward

To the extent that vantage centers inwards the encephalon are non nutrient specific, nosotros thought it made to sense to address other aspects of vantage inwards our lives. The engineering scientific discipline element was added to address the excessive number of hours nosotros were spending on the Internet. These hours included reading nutritional blogs, social networking sites, together with other surfing. We hypothesized a synergistic effect amongst Food Reward.

Some fundamental aspects of the Tech Reward experiment, also tracked inwards our Google Doc log

●     In bed yesteryear 9:30 PM - to eliminate the belatedly nighttime surfing, which also compromised sleep

●     Meditation – this was to assistance amongst both facets of the experiment

●     Removing ourselves from Facebook together with Paleohacks equally active members, together with also scouring the diverse nutritional blogs

Observations

Adherence to a depression vantage diet is a (Paleo-friendly) slice of cake compared to Technology Reward!!! It was incredibly hard to go without the social “rush” of the Internet. We had varying levels of success over the course of education of the 8 weeks.

When nosotros did really disengaged, it was real liberating. Life did non come upwardly to an destination when nosotros were no longer was abreast of each post on the diverse websites. Aravind was off Facebook for 3 weeks together with completely off the Internet for vii directly days (excluding utilitarian things similar going to his banking site). Until recently, he was off Paleohacks for exactly about half dozen weeks. Regarding his chronic slumber issues, the elimination of the belatedly nighttime surfing together with consistently going to slumber early (in add-on to dietary changes together with meditation) neither positively nor negatively impacted his sleep. As of calendar week 9, he started magnesium citrate supplementation, which initially seems to go positive, but the jury is silent out.

Kamal’s Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome issues were non noticeably dissimilar during the experiment. It should go noted that when his articulation hurting flared up, at that topographic point was a style to larn on the Internet (sometimes excessively) for stress relief. Perhaps this is similar to emotional situations leading to consumption of rewarding comfort foods. Kamal volition go along to exam his hypothesis that over fourth dimension amongst a Low Reward Lifestyle, the nervous organisation mightiness go meliorate equipped to bargain amongst noxious stimuli together with chronic hurting cycles. As hurting researchers say, “All hurting is inwards the brain”.

The bottom business is that nosotros tasted some of the fruits of a depression Tech Reward “diet”, but receive got a lot of go to create earlier declaring it a “lifestyle”.

Next Steps

“Focus together with simplicity” is our electrical flow mantra. We holler upwardly to go along the dietary element indefinitely until nosotros attain our target weight together with probable beyond. Regarding technology, equally noted nosotros are far from declaring “mission accomplished” together with demand to increase our efforts.

We would similar to give thank yous Stephan for giving us the chance to portion our experiences from the final 8 weeks, equally good equally the off-blog back upwardly provided. Stephan asked us to go real candid together with non “fructose-coat” our experiences fifty-fifty if the assessment was unfavorable. We are completely sold on Food Reward equally a therapeutic mensurate to address weight issues (coupled amongst an Ancestral diet for full general health). The debates regarding the usage of the discussion “dominant” together with causation of obesity are an academic exercise from our betoken of persuasion since nosotros are non biochemists, nor create nosotros play 1 on TV. Our objective is unproblematic – to exhibit upwardly Mark Sisson at AHS12 amongst our abs of steel. You’ve been served!

Stephan's Comments

Both Aravind together with Kamal lost fatty eating unproblematic nutrient without deliberately restricting calories (calorie intake declined naturally due to a reduction inwards appetite).  Kamal's simplified diet was high inwards poly peptide together with relatively depression inwards carbohydrate, spell Aravind's centered about carbohydrate.  Although weight loss was pocket-sized (12 lbs each), maintain inwards heed that a) they were scarcely overweight to laid out with, b) they are at nowadays inside 7-8 lbs of their ideal weight together with may go along to lose, together with c) they broke through a weight loss plateau that they had reached eating a paleo-ish diet.  Given those caveats, I holler upwardly their weight loss is really pretty impressive.  Point (c) is highly pregnant inwards my view, because it offers hope to people who experience that their fatty loss efforts receive got stalled out on other diets prior to reaching their target weight.  

I want to go clear that I'm non trying to devalue or supervene upon the paleo diet inwards whatsoever way-- I'm trying to refine it.  "Paleo" is a useful concept, together with it tin create goodness from incorporating simplicity, an of import appear of ancestral diets.  

Both Aravind together with Kamal adapted good to the simplified diet, withal their experiences differed considerably.  Aravind had to overcome a major diet soda addiction together with this may receive got contributed to his initial difficulties.  Kamal adapted immediately.  After adaptation, both consumed fewer calories than they required for weight maintenance, spontaneously together with without hunger.  Aravind was able to eliminate snacking due to a reduction inwards hunger.  It's real mutual for people to receive got problem adapting to unproblematic nutrient for the start 1-2 weeks (which I holler upwardly is real informative because it shows exactly how attached nosotros are to high-reward food), but most volition arrange together with grow to go satisfied yesteryear it.  H5N1 less painful option to the "cold turkey" approach is to gradually simplify your nutrient over a menses of weeks or months.

I also want to go clear that I never made whatsoever claims close the vantage concepts existence a handling for Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, which is a heritable connexion tissue disorder.  I suggested that a simplified diet may assist amongst fatty loss, together with a simplified lifestyle may assist amongst clarity/calmness (and perhaps slumber issues). 

The engineering scientific discipline vantage appear of their experiment was interesting equally well.  Although they benefited from the change, it did non assist Aravind's slumber problems.  I silent holler upwardly it tin assist some people slumber better, peculiarly those who don't slumber good due to stress, an overactive mind, or low-cal exposure from a calculator covert at night. But non everyone sleeps poorly for the same reasons.

I'd similar to give thank yous Aravind together with Kamal for offering to portion their experiences amongst the WHS community.

Does anyone else receive got a nutrient vantage experience they'd similar to portion (positive or negative)?  Please post it inwards the comments!

Share this post